diff --git a/app/models/filter.rb b/app/models/filter.rb
index 772e80c8b..a92b3a402 100644
--- a/app/models/filter.rb
+++ b/app/models/filter.rb
@@ -19,8 +19,8 @@ class Filter < ApplicationRecord
   def cards
     @cards ||= begin
       result = creator.accessible_cards.indexed_by(indexed_by)
-      result = result.where(id: card_ids) if card_ids.present? && !indexed_by.closed?
-      result = result.open unless indexed_by.closed?
+      result = result.where(id: card_ids) if card_ids.present?
+      result = result.open unless indexed_by.closed? || card_ids.present?
       result = result.by_engagement_status(engagement_status) if engagement_status.present?
       result = result.unassigned if assignment_status.unassigned?
       result = result.assigned_to(assignees.ids) if assignees.present?